January 19, 2006 10:08
I recently read a very interesting post on Jeff Atwood post: Filesystems Aren't a Feature. He starts pointing out an observation done by a developer watching his relatives using the pc:
When I observe how my wife and son uses the family computer, I can't help noticing how little use they have for the desktop. They look bewildered when I open the Windows Explorer. To them, file open or file save dialog is where the files go. My Documents? It's just an icon they never touch.I don't even know why the open dialog (and the save dialog) and the File Manager (Explorer) should be different. They have the same function: locate a file. In his post Jeff consider alternatives to the direct exposure of the file system to the user. I agree that the File System hierachical structure -with files, folders, and different partitions- is confusing, but we should wonder in the first place why open/save dialogs ("where the files go") is different from My Computer. If they were identical, sharing the same interface, would it be so confusing? I don't think so..